
Completely agree with Atrios on this. The punditocrisy and their cable news cronies are incredibly unhip! It's part and parcel of their career-abetting instinct to keep slinging the stale storylines and hackneyed images that show their seriousness. Hipness requires at least the illusion of freshness.
Which is why using the 'Kewl Kidz' moniker to refer to these caricatures has never seemed right to me. It captures their clubbiness, but not their banality, and vests them with an undue power. Rather than Heathers/Mean Girls, the proper analogy is Animal House/Revenge of the Nerds. In the college comedy genre, a straight-laced coalition of bullies, elitists, legacy brats, and slavish pledges, sporting J Crew and feigning high seriousness, always tries to wipe out the Dirty Fucking Hippies, who are clearly having Way More Fun! And The Dirty Fucking Hippies always win.....
Which is why using the 'Kewl Kidz' moniker to refer to these caricatures has never seemed right to me. It captures their clubbiness, but not their banality, and vests them with an undue power. Rather than Heathers/Mean Girls, the proper analogy is Animal House/Revenge of the Nerds. In the college comedy genre, a straight-laced coalition of bullies, elitists, legacy brats, and slavish pledges, sporting J Crew and feigning high seriousness, always tries to wipe out the Dirty Fucking Hippies, who are clearly having Way More Fun! And The Dirty Fucking Hippies always win.....